by Nomad
Controversy over "Confederate"
Recently HBO announced its plan to produce an alternative history called
Confederate, which poses the question
"What if the South had won the Civil War? What would America look like today?"
"What if..." has always been a source of great fiction but this decision sparked off a round of protests online. This was, many people felt, a really bad idea.
Co-creator
David Benioff felt compelled to respond to the objections. He said that while he had "great respect" for critics, he also said that HBO also hoped that the public would
"reserve judgment until there is something to see.”
Indeed, there isn't even a script yet. Benioff's comment might seem reasonable, at first glance. Yet. national correspondent for The Atlantic,
Ta-Nehisi Coates, isn't buying it and explains why this bit of historical fiction is an idea whose time has
not come.
